If you are considering installing a new garage door, whether for a first-time homeowner or to replace an outdated one, you probably know there are different materials to choose from. Each garage door material has pros and cons; understanding them is imperative in helping you make the right selection for your residential or commercial property.
Garage Door Materials: The Pros and Cons
If you’re looking for a new garage door, there are a variety of styles and materials to choose from. Consider which garage door material is best for your house and needs.
Think About These Features Before Making Your Decision:
Durability: A garage door protects the valuables inside your garage and home. Consider a sturdy garage door material that can withstand moisture or insect damage, especially in a humid climate.
Energy efficiency: Insulated garage doors can help block unpleasant air drafts, regulate the temperature of your home, and save money on energy costs.
Aesthetic appeal: Garage doors make up a large percentage of your home’s exterior. The suitable garage door material can enhance your home’s curb appeal.
Cost: Weigh the short-term and long-term costs and savings to help determine which garage door materials are best for your home.
Steel Garage Doors
All climates
Steel is one of the most common garage door materials due to its durability and affordability.
A steel garage door can provide you with a level of durability and security you can’t get from other garage door materials. Steel is a sturdy material that can enhance your garage’s security and resist Mother Nature’s power. Thanks to that durability, you get a door that requires less maintenance.
Pros of Steel Garage Doors
- Strength and security
- Energy-efficient
- Low maintenance
- Variety of styles
- Budget-friendly
Cons of Steel Garage Doors
- Susceptibility to rust
- Not a natural insulator
- Subject to corrosion in salty environments
Wood Garage Doors
Mild, dry climates
Wood is often the second-most popular option for garage doors. Wood doors have existed since the very early days of garage door use.
Wood is preferred over other materials because of its aesthetic appeal. It gives your garage door a unique and distinguished look, and it can be customized to fit any style or design you want.
Pros of Wood Garage Doors
- Aesthetically pleasing
- Customization
- Good insulation
- Repairability
Cons of Wood Garage Doors
- Higher maintenance
- Cost
- Vulnerability to weather
- Can crack, warp, swell, or rot
- Shorter lifespan
Aluminum Garage Doors
All Climates; However, Eextreme Heat can Reduce Durability
This material is somewhat similar to steel, and many property owners use it as an alternative. Aluminum offers similar advantages to steel but at a lower price. It is strong, long-lasting, and, thanks to aluminum’s natural resistance, does not rust.
Aluminum doors are also perfect for fitting with many glass window options, which allow more natural light into the garage and give a home a beautiful contemporary look.
However, aluminum is lighter than steel. Because it’s lighter, aluminum is more likely to dent and does not last as long as steel, especially in areas with high wind speeds.
Pros of Aluminum Garage Doors
- Lightweight
- Low maintenance
- Modern aesthetics
- Cost-effective option
- Large glass windows allow maximum light to go into the garage
Cons of Aluminum Garage Doors
- Not fully waterproof
- Poor insulation
- Less privacy when fitted with glass windows
- Less durable
Fiberglass Garage Doors
Warm, Humid Climates
Though uncommon, fiberglass material is best for garage doors fitted in highly salty areas such as beachfront properties. Fiberglass panels are extremely durable, more dent-resistant than steel, and highly resistant to corrosion or rust.
Their high resistance to corrosion makes fiberglass a perfect option for coastal properties. In addition, fiberglass requires almost zero maintenance. However, it is a poor insulator and may fade due to long exposure to the sun.
Pros of Fiberglass Garage Doors
- Durability
- Lightweight
- Low maintenance
- Won’t contract or expand from temperature changes
- Resistant to warping, shrinking, or corroding due to moisture
Cons of Fiberglass Garage Doors
- Fiberglass is brittle and is more susceptible to damage
- Will often crack and develop a yellow tint with age
- Cost
- May not provide the same level of insulation
Vinyl Garage Doors
Vinyl is quickly becoming one of the most popular garage door materials. This is because it offers the best of both worlds between wood and steel. It provides the charm of wood with the affordability and durability of steel. Vinyl garage doors can be a good choice for a variety of climates, including coast regions, humid summers, and extreme weather:
- Coastal regions: Vinyl is resistant to salt air, wind, and sand and can withstand coastal storms. It’s also a good alternative to wood, which can warp or rot in humid conditions.
- Humid summers: Vinyl is maintenance-free and won’t rust, fade, or dent.
- Extreme weather: Vinyl can handle low temperatures, high moisture, and freeze/thaw cycles. However, vinyl may become brittle and crack if forcefully impacted in extremely cold climates. To help prevent this, you can ensure the door is insulated.
Pros of Vinyl Garage Doors
- Cost Effective
- Durable
- Low Maintenance
- Resistant to Dents, Cracks and Rust
- Weather resistance
Cons of Vinyl Garage Doors
- It only comes in light colors because darker colors will fade.
- You are stuck with your chosen color as the same color goes through the garage door.
Garage Door Materials: The Pros and Cons
If you are considering installing a new garage door, whether for a first-time homeowner or to replace an outdated one, you probably know there are different materials to choose from. Each garage door material [...]
Garage Door Trends 2024
The garage door industry is constantly evolving, and 2024 promises to bring some exciting trends and innovations to the forefront. Whether you’re a homeowner looking to upgrade your garage door or a builder planning [...]
Cost Vs. Value 2024
The Cost Vs. Value 2024 proves curb appeal is still the highest value for home improvement. The quest for the highest return on investment (ROI) for home improvement projects often leads homeowners to prioritize [...]
Is it Time for A New Garage Door?
Garage doors are one of the essential elements of your home. They provide security for your home and can occupy up to 30% of your home’s curb appeal. A new garage door could be [...]
Top Wood Garage Door Alternatives
The wood grain texture, rich look, and natural feel make wood garage doors a desired addition to many homes. Yet a wood garage door may not be for everyone, as natural wood doors can [...]
Wood Garage Door Tips
Wood garage doors are sophisticated additions to homes of every style. Due to their unique blend of aesthetic appeal, durability, and functionality, wood garage doors remain a top choice for homeowners. Yet, there's much [...]
Lifespan of Garage Doors & Openers
Your garage door is a focal point of your home and can add value and curb appeal. In addition to your garage door's beauty, it is also the main entrance to your home and [...]
Dock Safety
There is nothing that provides a better return than the investment you make in safety. Loading dock environments may be dangerous work areas and need safety features to protect workers and your business. Many [...]
Choosing a New Garage Door
An old or broken garage door can be a hassle and a safety issue. Purchasing a new garage door is an essential investment in your home's curb appeal and safety. There are various garage [...]
Keep Your Garage Organized and Clean
With the start of the new year, there’s no better time to keep your garage organized and clean, During the holidays, the garage often becomes the catchall for everything from lawn and garden equipment [...]
Benefits of Loading Dock Seals and Shelters
Your loading dock doors are extremely busy; therefore, as an owner, you must do everything possible to ensure they operate safely and efficiently. Loading dock seals and shelters are vital components of your dock [...]
Make Your Exterior Home Unique
When designing our dream home, Make Your Exterior Home Unique on the outside. A spectacular exterior will stand out and reflect the general style of the house. Beautiful house exterior design can be complemented [...]
Call us Today at (858) 264-3650
Overhead Door Company of Southern California™ – 12215 Kirkham Road Suite 200, Poway, CA 92064
Call Us Today at (858) 264-3650
Or Email us on the Form Below.
Business Hours: Monday – Friday 7 AM–4 PM
Call us Today at
(858) 264-3650
Or Send us an Email.